Wednesday, March 3, 2010

Argumentative essay

Should the experiment have taken place?

From Doctor Nemur and Doctor Strauss's point of view, I think they felt the experiment should have taken place. They just wanted to use Charlie as a test subject and they did not care whether Charlie was affected by the experiment so that they could get famous.

From Charlie’s parents’ point of view, they would probably ask Charlie to take the operation as it can improve their son’s mental capabilities and there could be more communication between them. But if they knew the full consequence of the operation, they probably would not let him take the operation too.

From Fanny’s point of view, she probably would not want Charlie to take the experiment as it is going against god to meddle with intelligence.

From Mr. Steven Ng’s point of view, he probably would ask Charlie to take the experiment as he would be able to get a lot of money.

From Charlie’s colleague’s point of view, I think they would prefer Charlie when he was retarded, as they had more fun making fun of him before the operation.

Finally, from my point of view, I feel that Charlie should not have gone for the operation as he was happier before the operation and he was more clever before the operation. But if he knew he had made a great contribution to science, he would probably be happy too.

No comments:

Post a Comment